Pope sets time frame for forgiveness
“A priest, a minister, and a rabbi walk into a bar…” And you know the rest. You don’t? Neither do I. But there’s got to be a good joke out there that starts this way. And maybe provoking a smile would be a good way to start out this post, seeing as how it’s critical of the Catholic Church, and I’m going to be stepping on some family toes again. But, then again, it’s no laughing matter. Though my Catholic family members and friends are good and gracious people and I love them, the Roman Catholic Church merits scrutiny because she claims for herself the position of the “one, true Church” in Christendom, effectively condemning Christians like me who are outside of her fold. Are her teachings and proclamations true? It needs to be asked…often.
So the Pope just announced that beginning this December 8 and through November 20 of 2016 all Catholic priests are granted “the discretion to absolve of the sin of abortion those who have procured it and who, with contrite heart, seek forgiveness for it.” Outside of this block of days that constitutes the Catholic Church’s Jubilee Year of Mercy, any Catholic girl or woman who gets an abortion is automatically excommunicated from the Church1, leaving her in danger of hell fire.
Now, I’m passionately pro-life, as anyone who searches my blog posts could easily discern, and believe abortion to be no less than murder. It’s a sin…a grave one. But it’s unbiblical, unChristlike, and just plain wrong for the Catholic Church to designate some sins as un-absolvable no matter the presence or lack of true repentance. Jesus never did.*
There are so many untruths associated with this news. Please consider…
- First of all, as is implied with just about any news item involving the Christian faith, this is, supposedly, the face of the faith. Roman Catholicism, especially as represented by the Pope, is the go-to denomination whenever news outlets cover the Easter and Christmas holidays and religiopolitical issues. So that those relatively unfamiliar with Christianity are led to believe that whatever the Pope says is according to universal, orthodox, biblical Christianity. Those of us who are familiar with both the Bible and the RCC know that to be untrue. Please read my series on the Catholic Church for an overview on some of her unique and unbiblical teachings and practices.
- The second untruth is that the Catholic Church stands in the place of God himself on earth in having the authority to declare abortion to be a sin so much graver than others that it requires the removal of the sinner from his church…even though Jesus taught that the sin of murder is a heart issue and all who angrily call someone a “fool” are in danger of hell fire as well.2 And the apostle John said that, “Everyone who hates his brother is a murderer…”3 Though unrepentant, unregenerate murderers are listed in Revelation 21:8 as among those who will be eternally condemned, so are “the sexually immoral…and all liars.” If fornication and lying can be forgiven upon confession, why not abortion?
- Another falsehood being promoted with this Jubilee Year is that of the “indulgence.” An indulgence in the Catholic Church is, “a remission before God of the temporal punishment due to sins whose guilt has already been forgiven…”4 Please read my post on indulgences here for more details. The indulgence the Pope is offering the faithful is a reduction in time spent in “purgatory” if sometime during this upcoming Jubilee Year of Mercy they make a pilgrimage to the “Holy Door” of a Catholic cathedral or one of a number of other designated churches or shrines. Purgatory and indulgences are in no way supported by Scripture.
- “The forgiveness of God cannot be denied to one who has repented…” This IS true and is quoted from Pope Francis’ letter on this issue dated yesterday. The untruth is that the Catholic Church can somehow manipulate God’s forgiveness to certain days or upon completion of certain activities, like confession to a priest or pilgrimages to Holy Doors. I’m sure many Catholics will quote John 20:23, “If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you withhold forgiveness from any, it is withheld.” They interpret that to mean that the Church has the authority to decide whether or not a sin should be forgiven. But Jesus spoke this to his “disciples,” not the Twelve, and all Christ-followers are his disciples. And if he meant that some sins even though repented of cannot be forgiven, what did John mean in 1 John 1:9, “If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness”?
God’s abundant mercy, love, forgiveness, and his plan of salvation are greatly compromised when people are led astray to believe that their sins are too great to be among those cast “as far as the east is from the west.”5 Or that they must be confessed to a priest. But, “confess your sins to one another and pray for one another, that you may be healed.”6 And, “godly grief produces a repentance that leads to salvation without regret.”7
1 Catechism of the Catholic Church #2272
2 Matthew 5:22
3 1 John 3:15
4 Catechism of the Catholic Church #1471
5 Psalm 103:12
6 James 5:16
7 2 Corinthians 7:10
*The “unforgivable sin” against the Holy Spirit that Jesus spoke of in Matthew 12:31 is almost certainly the sin of unbelief.
Classic! So, let me get this straight… You don’t like a religious organisation dictating to you how a social issue should be handled?
Meditate on that, Caroline.
LikeLike
John, you seem to have quite missed the point. But, never mind that…I’d like to ask you a question: Do you believe murder is wrong?
LikeLike
Hi Caroline
What point did I miss? But don’t you find it interesting that you’re complaining about a religious organisation imposing their beliefs on you?
And of course I find murder wrong. Of course, states have legalised murder in the form of wars. Why do you ask?
LikeLike
My point was not that the Catholic Church is imposing its beliefs on me. It was that they claim to be the true church but in fact much of what they hold and teach is untrue.
On what basis do you hold that murder is wrong?
LikeLike
It was that they claim to be the true church but in fact much of what they hold and teach is untrue.
And what, Caroline, is a “true church”? There are 42,000 Christian sects, and each one claims to be the “true church.” If we go by numbers alone, there are six-times more Catholics than evangelicals, so that would make them, by popularity, the true church.
But you seem to have missed my point. It’s hilarious to now see a theist whining about another religious organisation trying to impose their beliefs on others. Maybe, just maybe, you’d start to see how we feel when all you guys try to impose your beliefs on us.
Murder is wrong because it’s the killing of a human being. But, as I pointed out, we legalise murder in times of war. How many Iraqi civilians did the US kill last decade, 1.2 million?
LikeLike
You didn’t answer my question. You simply stated what murder is.
LikeLike
I said, “Murder is wrong because it’s the killing of a human being.”
What’s your point?
Now, don’t you find it amusing that you’re complaining about a religious organisation imposing their unjustified beliefs on you?
LikeLike
John, my point is to get you to see that you need the forgiveness I talked about in this post. You intuitively recognize the evil of murder, but apart from theism you have no grounding for it as being objectively wrong. I don’t want to argue with you. I want you to recognize the evil in your own heart and know that there is only one way to be forgiven of it, and that is through Jesus.
LikeLike
Sorry, Caroline, but what do I need forgiveness for?
So, you think killing is objectively wrong, do you? I have no idea what this has to do with abortion because nothing is being killed. You know that. Your own government, however, recently killed 1.2 million Iraqi civilians. Did you protest that? Was that objectively wrong? What about World War 2, was all that killing objectively wrong? Your own government has the death penalty. Is that objectively wrong? Do you protest that, or do you rationally justify it somehow?
Now, back to the point at hand… This post of yours is fantastic! Truly, truly fantastic. Here you are, complaining that a religious group is imposing their beliefs (unjustified beliefs, that is) on you. Like I said, maybe you will now begin to understand how we all feel about people like you, Caroline, trying to impose your unjustified beliefs on us.
LikeLike
But don’t you see, John…on atheism you have no basis from which to judge that any of those killings were wrong.
LikeLike
Really? So, you can’t tell right from wrong by yourself, huh?
Interesting…
LikeLike
You’re making it very clear, John, that you have no way to defend morality from your worldview. For your own sake…have the courage to objectively consider what you profess to be true and whether or not you are stealing from the theistic worldview to lodge complaints and objections against it.
LikeLike
So you are indeed saying that you’re incapable of determining for yourself whether something is right or wrong.
Again, interesting…..
Do you support slavery, Caroline?
LikeLike
Pingback: My Choice (by Jezabel Jonson) | From guestwriters